White Elephants Shouldn't Roam the Berg

18 Jul 2013 08:23 #58416 by Vertical Endeavour

The idea of a cable car in the Drakensberg is not new. It has however recently received fresh impetus and media attention. Various locations for the project have been considered, in particular the Mnweni area situated in the Northern Drakensberg. As a group of concerned people who are very familiar with the Mnweni, and who cumulatively have been exploring the Drakensberg for many decades, we are concerned that this project will become a white elephant should it go ahead. We believe the idea is particularly unsuited to the Mnweni and that it is neither sustainable nor desirable in the Berg as a whole.

Read more...

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
07 Sep 2013 18:44 #58417 by Philip
It is my opinion that there is already a 'cable-way' in the Drakensberg, it is called Sani Pass. The main difference is that the gondolas are individually motorized! Why do we need another 'cable-way'? Anyone wanting to access the High Berg without expending any energy, and in relative comfort can do so. The infrastructure to receive tourists at the top is already in place. All the views and vistas are there, with the added attraction of driving on to Black Mountain Pass and into Lesotho. If the weather is inclement, the motorized gondolas stop running, with no expensive equipment lying dormant. The tourist industry servicing Sani Pass has evolved to meet a demand - much more healthy than setting up infrastructure and then attempting to create a demand!
The following user(s) said Thank You: Serious tribe, plouw, Viking

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
07 Sep 2013 19:15 #58418 by ghaznavid
I completely agree...
The following user(s) said Thank You: Philip

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Sep 2013 19:18 - 09 Sep 2013 19:19 #58438 by intrepid

The cable car will be a unique development that attracts people to the area and will provide the easiest and only way for many people to access the escarpment. Currently there are only two ways to access the escarpment top – by foot or by 4x4 up Sani Pass. Neither of these options are available to most tourists. We believe the cable car will fill the gap and provide this access to the most scenic parts of the Drakensberg to a whole new market of people. These include:
- School groups
- Tour buses
- Disabled people
- Time sensitive tourists
- People with limited finances
- Elderly people

Page 40 of the recent feasibility study

I never really agreed with the statement that Sani Pass was not available to "most tourists". I tend to agree with you Philip. In my view Sani Pass is an argument against the cable car, not an argument for it. Or are we missing something here?

Take nothing but litter, leave nothing but a cleaner Drakensberg.
Last edit: 09 Sep 2013 19:19 by intrepid.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Philip

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Sep 2013 19:39 - 09 Sep 2013 19:42 #58440 by ghaznavid
That was one of the points in my reply, I must get to writing that sometime soon...

intrepid wrote:

These include:
- Tour buses


It it just me, or is that a major contradiction :lol:

As for the others:
- why can't a school group go up Sani Pass? Doesn't make much sense
- the reason a disabled person can't go up Sani Pass is that the bathrooms up there aren't wheelchair accessible. I know this due to having tried to make a plan to get my mother's best friend up there. She loves the Berg and has been in a wheelchair since she was 3. That is a fairly cheap and easy problem to fix vs a cable car
- Time sensitive tourists won't drive to Mnweni to start with. Also Cobham is closer to Durban - to the top of Sani Pass is 249km per Google Maps - compared to Mnweni - 266km per Google Maps.
- People with limited finances? R228 for a ticket vs roughly the same for the Sani taxi isn't it?
- Elderly people? What stops them from using Sani Pass?
Last edit: 09 Sep 2013 19:42 by ghaznavid.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Philip

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
10 Sep 2013 07:11 #58444 by Philip
'Tour buses' - Tour buses are already catered for on Sani Pass. They park in Underberg, or at a local hotel. Tourists are then transferred into 'individually motorized gondolas', and back into their tour buses after the trip. Each 'gondola' has its own driver / guide, providing employment and supporting the local tourist industry!

'People with limited finances' - They have two options - they can walk up Sani Pass from the SA border control (3hrs up 2hrs down) - this is completely safe as they cannot get lost, and if they have a 'problem' can easily be rescued. Second option - use the local 4x4 taxis!

'Time sensitive tourists' - (whatever that means) - Several 'gondola' operators will run a half day trip - a complete travesty in my opinion, but there you are!

'Wheelchair access' - Plans are well developed for a rebuilt 'Sani Top Chalet' - now called 'Sani Mountain Lodge'. I am quite sure that wheelchair access will have been considered. I will check with the managers when I am next up there...

'School groups' - School groups are often accessing the High Berg and Lesotho via Sani Pass. As a guide I have been involved in many trips...

An additional point is that the existing Underberg / SA tourist industry is making positive contributions to the Lesotho communities at Sani Top and further afield. This adds an important 'cross-cultural' element to Sani Pass trips. This will not be the case above the Mnweni area, as there are no permanent Basotho communities anywhere nearby.

Visitors to the Sani Pass area can access some of the most stunning day hikes - for example Hodgson's Peaks, and of course Thabana Ntlenyana. Even simply walking out along the 'Twelve Apostles' is as rewarding as anywhere else. (Yes, I know we all have our favorite secret places that we will argue are more spectacular - but tourists don't know them do they?! ;) Sani Stone Lodge (see my posting 'Alternative Accommodation at Sani Top') can offer the unique opportunity of riding horses along the top of the Drakensberg Escarpment, and inland to isolated Basotho villages. Riding horses along the top of the Drakensberg is an experience not to be missed (if you get on with horses!). Organizing that experience anywhere else along the top of the KZN Drakensberg is logistically so complex that it is almost not worth it.

I completely agree that Sani Pass is an argument against the cable car and is exactly the point I am making in this post!
The following user(s) said Thank You: plouw, ghaznavid, tonymarshall

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
Powered by Kunena Forum