Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
20 Jul 2017 20:00 #71901
by ghaznavid
Replied by ghaznavid on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
Facebook conversation with him. The rules specify n-s. His exact words were something along the lines of "it's not the same course".
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 Jul 2017 07:03 #71903
by Stijn
Replied by Stijn on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
Hmmm... agreed that it's not quite the same course, but since there are so few attempts on the entire thing, I have always felt that the minor differences can be lumped together as one record.
Sure, we can acknowledge details like direction taken, solo vs group, etc - as long as the style of the attempt is transparent, people can make their own judgements on the relative merits of each.
Sure, we can acknowledge details like direction taken, solo vs group, etc - as long as the style of the attempt is transparent, people can make their own judgements on the relative merits of each.
The following user(s) said Thank You: AdrianT
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 Jul 2017 08:11 - 21 Jul 2017 08:12 #71904
by tonymarshall
Replied by tonymarshall on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
I'm totally in agreement with Stijn's comments and approach.
Stijn, assuming you know who compiled the rules, would there be merit in attempting to get the wording changed to 'officially' recognise DGT speed attempts in either direction, all the other conditions remaining in effect?
Stijn, assuming you know who compiled the rules, would there be merit in attempting to get the wording changed to 'officially' recognise DGT speed attempts in either direction, all the other conditions remaining in effect?
Last edit: 21 Jul 2017 08:12 by tonymarshall.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tonymarshall
-
- Offline
- VE Advisory
-
Less
More
- Posts: 768
- Thank you received: 2233
21 Jul 2017 11:10 #71907
by Stijn
Replied by Stijn on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
Most of the online references to the rules seem to have been taken from my write-up of our first attempt back in 2006 (hence the N-S bias). The only vaguely "official" place these are listed (that I know of) is: www.featsa.co.za/2011/07/feats-on-foot/
I'll chat to Lisa to edit that content. Let me know if there's anywhere else?
I'll chat to Lisa to edit that content. Let me know if there's anywhere else?
The following user(s) said Thank You: tonymarshall
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 Jul 2017 12:06 #71909
by DesPorter
Replied by DesPorter on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
See MCSA journal number 102 for 1999 for the write up of the original challenge by Gavin Raubenheimer. He did it north to south and incidentally all summit traverses I have done have also been north to south but could also have been done south to north. The main reason for my doing them north to south was that the northern starting point was closer to home.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 Jul 2017 16:27 #71911
by ghaznavid
Replied by ghaznavid on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
I agree with Stijn as well, it most certainly isn't Comrades where there are enough times to justify separate records, and notably the course isn't exactly the same there either. For that matter, it is varied from time to time, yet still considered comparable.
Also with a record like Everest, the different sides meet at the top, but most of the route is different. A DGT route either way can be done by the identical route - and the rules allow enough variations that direction is less of a factor than a call such as Yodelers vs Didima Gully.
I guess the question is - will previous record holders accept this rule change?
Also with a record like Everest, the different sides meet at the top, but most of the route is different. A DGT route either way can be done by the identical route - and the rules allow enough variations that direction is less of a factor than a call such as Yodelers vs Didima Gully.
I guess the question is - will previous record holders accept this rule change?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
05 Dec 2017 19:24 - 05 Dec 2017 19:25 #72453
by Papa Dragon
Any idea of route for the Lower Traverse, or where I could find out? Hiking, not running
Thanks
Replied by Papa Dragon on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
Macc wrote:
ghaznavid wrote: To the best of my knowledge, this has never been done in its entirety
Jack Davis, Michelle Davis and Andrew Booth ran a 'Lower Traverse' over Christmas last year, Bushman's Nek to Royal Natal. facebook.com/drakensberglowertraverse
Any idea of route for the Lower Traverse, or where I could find out? Hiking, not running
Thanks
Last edit: 05 Dec 2017 19:25 by Papa Dragon.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Papa Dragon
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 763
- Thank you received: 647
10 Dec 2018 08:35 #74340
by relihanm
Replied by relihanm on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
End year GT anyone?
It has been a while since my first khulu-bagging GT with ghaznavid and andrewp www.vertical-endeavour.com/forum/grand-traverse-write-ups/55708-gt2014-15-don-t-follow-the-lights.html?start=0 and I was keen to do the standard North to South GT within a week over the upcoming Christmas - New Year (2018-2019) block. With ghaznavid overseas and andrewp otherwise occupied in that time I was wondering if anyone else, or any group, is planning to do a GT like this that I could join, or could we set up something? I have only done 2 berg hikes this year so far, but have arranged to join the Mountain Club Mweni hike this coming weekend to evaluate my hiking preparedness. I have been doing CrossFit and cycling this year and should not be unfit otherwise. I am more worried about feet trauma especially since I just bought new hiking boots that I have not worn yet to replace my previous boots that shrunk to much after stupidly trying to dry them out in an oven after a wet hike.
Anyone interested out there is welcome to give me a call (084-5119445). Alternatively, I could try to schedule some Berg trad climbing as an alternative within this time slot, but I have not climbed for quite a while so it would have to be conservative grades and I have not picked any routes.
It has been a while since my first khulu-bagging GT with ghaznavid and andrewp www.vertical-endeavour.com/forum/grand-traverse-write-ups/55708-gt2014-15-don-t-follow-the-lights.html?start=0 and I was keen to do the standard North to South GT within a week over the upcoming Christmas - New Year (2018-2019) block. With ghaznavid overseas and andrewp otherwise occupied in that time I was wondering if anyone else, or any group, is planning to do a GT like this that I could join, or could we set up something? I have only done 2 berg hikes this year so far, but have arranged to join the Mountain Club Mweni hike this coming weekend to evaluate my hiking preparedness. I have been doing CrossFit and cycling this year and should not be unfit otherwise. I am more worried about feet trauma especially since I just bought new hiking boots that I have not worn yet to replace my previous boots that shrunk to much after stupidly trying to dry them out in an oven after a wet hike.
Anyone interested out there is welcome to give me a call (084-5119445). Alternatively, I could try to schedule some Berg trad climbing as an alternative within this time slot, but I have not climbed for quite a while so it would have to be conservative grades and I have not picked any routes.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
14 Dec 2018 07:42 #74378
by Drakie1
Replied by Drakie1 on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
I am looking for someone to join me on a Drakensberg Grand Traverse at the end of April 2019.
This will be my second attempt. I attempted it together with a friend of mine in April 2018. Unfortunately he developed inflammation in his right ankle and we had to quit after six days, coming down Organ Pipes pass, down to Cathedral Peak Hotel.
Anyone interested?
This will be my second attempt. I attempted it together with a friend of mine in April 2018. Unfortunately he developed inflammation in his right ankle and we had to quit after six days, coming down Organ Pipes pass, down to Cathedral Peak Hotel.
Anyone interested?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
18 Dec 2018 04:54 #74387
by HenkSeevinck
Replied by HenkSeevinck on topic Who is doing or has done the Grand Traverse
PM Sent
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- HenkSeevinck
-
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 32
- Thank you received: 4





